📅 公開日:
💡 Why are permanent residency applications in Japan denied?
The Immigration Services Agency’s guidelines point to several common problems: unpaid or late taxes, pension and health insurance contributions; insufficient household income; fines or other criminal penalties; missed immigration notifications; and not meeting the residence period requirements. For applications filed on or after April 1, 2027, time spent abroad, expected pension benefits and Japanese ability (B1 level) will also be considered. The decision is highly discretionary, so it pays to find your weak points and prepare explanations and evidence before you apply.
In this article:
- The main reasons for denial, based on the official guidelines
- How the review changes depending on when you apply
- A pre-application checklist
- What happens to your status after a denial, and reapplying
Permanent residency in Japan denied: where do the reasons come from?
If you want to understand why permanent residency in Japan gets denied, the most reliable starting point is the Immigration Services Agency’s (ISA) Guidelines for Permanent Residence. We could not find an official list of denial reasons for ordinary permanent residence applications in ISA’s published materials, so this article focuses on the factors the guidelines say will be assessed negatively.
There are three legal requirements:
- Good conduct: you obey the law and live without social reproach.
- Independent livelihood: you will not be a public burden and can expect a stable life in the future.
- National interest: your permanent residence benefits Japan. This covers length of residence and meeting obligations such as paying taxes.
Spouses and children of Japanese nationals, permanent residents and special permanent residents do not need to meet the first two, but the national interest requirement still applies. The guidelines only set out basic factors, and each case is decided on all of its circumstances.
Which guidelines apply depends on when you file
| When you apply | Which guidelines apply |
|---|---|
| April 1, 2026 – March 31, 2027 | The February 24, 2026 version, except that the income and public burden sections of the October 1, 2026 version apply |
| On or after April 1, 2027 | The October 1, 2026 version |
For a full overview of the changes, see our article on the October 2026 guideline revision.
Reason 1: Unpaid or late taxes, pension and health insurance

Paying late can be a problem even if you have since paid in full. Under the February 2026 version, payments not made by the original due date are in principle assessed negatively even if nothing is outstanding when you apply. The October 2026 version also treats past failures to pay, such as having been subject to a delinquency disposition, as a negative factor in principle, and generally reviews this by household.
The required documents are designed to show whether you paid on time:
| Your current status | Residence tax | Pension and health insurance |
|---|---|---|
| Work-related statuses and Dependent | Most recent 5 years of tax certificates, plus proof of on-time payment (not needed if all tax was deducted from salary) | Most recent 2 years |
| Spouse of Japanese National or of Permanent Resident | Most recent 3 years of tax certificates, plus proof of on-time payment (not needed if all tax was deducted from salary) | Most recent 2 years |
Employees should check the gaps between jobs in particular, since you pay National Pension and National Health Insurance yourself during those periods. Keep your receipts and bank records. National tax payment certificates (Form 3) are also required, and the full document list depends on your status.
Reason 2: Insufficient household income or unstable finances
The October 2026 income standard already applies to applications filed on or after April 1, 2026. ISA considers whether your household income has continuously reached a level above the average income of Japanese households of the same size.
- Incomes of family members who share living expenses are added together.
- Income earned by family members on a non-work status such as Dependent is not added.
- Dependents count toward household size even if they live overseas.
The guidelines do not state a yen amount. Take particular care if you support several dependents or are counting on a spouse’s part-time income.
Reason 3: Fines, other penalties and repeated traffic violations
Having received a fine or imprisonment is in principle assessed negatively, as are certain juvenile protective measures.
The guidelines have no specific rule on traffic violations alone. However, repeated illegal or antisocial behavior means failing the good conduct requirement, and a criminal fine for a traffic offense is still a fine. If you have any violations, write down exactly when they happened and what they were.
Reason 4: Missed immigration notifications and working outside your status
This covers notifying your address and changes of employer, carrying your residence card, and staying within the activities you are permitted to do. Under the October 2026 version, past violations are in principle assessed negatively even if you are in compliance when you apply. Check that you reported every move and job change, and that part-time work never exceeded the hours allowed.
Reason 5: Not meeting the residence period requirements

In principle, you need 10 years of continuous residence, including 5 continuous years on a work or residence-based status. You also need to hold the longest period of stay available for your current status. Common pitfalls:
- Time as a Technical Intern or Specified Skilled Worker (i) does not count toward the 5 years. The October 2026 version also excludes Employment for Skill Development and Intra-company Transferee.
- A 3-year period of stay is treated as the longest period for applications filed by March 31, 2027. From April 1, 2027, this applies only to certain first-time applications.
- Some temporary Designated Activities, such as job hunting after graduation, do not count toward the 10 years.
- The special route for spouses changes from 3 years of marriage and 1 year of residence to 5 years of marriage and 3 years of residence for applications filed on or after April 1, 2027.
New factors for applications filed from April 2027
| Factor | What is considered |
|---|---|
| Time abroad | Within the past 10 years, being away for six months or more in one trip, or two years and six months or more in total, without a reasonable reason is in principle negative |
| Expected pension | Whether your expected benefits reach a set level (financial assets that cover the gap are taken into account) |
| Japanese ability | B1 level or above (not considered for highly skilled professionals and their families, people with six or more years of primary or secondary education in Japan, and some others) |
| Understanding of rules | Checked by a method ISA designates (the guidelines do not yet give details) |
| Children’s schooling | School-age children should attend elementary or junior high school |
Incomplete documents and weak explanations
ISA warns that incomplete applications may face long delays or an unfavorable decision. Certificates issued in Japan must be dated within three months, and you will also need a letter of guarantee and a signed letter of understanding.
ISA’s self-check sheet says that any “No” answer makes a denial more likely, and that all “Yes” answers do not guarantee approval. If something in your history is unfavorable, explain the facts, the background and what you have changed, with supporting evidence.
Pre-application checklist
- Everyone in the household has paid residence tax, pension and health insurance on time.
- You have kept receipts and bank records for the required years.
- Household income has been stable (not just after a job change or a drop in pay).
- You have a record of any fines or penalties, with dates and details.
- All notifications of address and employer changes were made.
- You meet the residence period and hold the longest period of stay.
- You have reviewed your travel history for the past 10 years.
- You have considered whether to file before or after April 1, 2027.
If your application is denied: your status and reapplying

Applying for permanent residence does not extend your current period of stay. If your period of stay will expire during the review, you must separately apply for an extension before it expires. A denial does not by itself take away your current status, but keep a close eye on your expiry date.
The application fee is paid only when permission is granted, so no fee is payable for a denied application.
Article 7(1)(x) of the Administrative Complaint Review Act excludes “dispositions concerning the entry and exit of foreign nationals or naturalization” from its request-for-review provisions. In practice, the realistic path is usually to identify what went wrong and prepare a new application.
- Find out why: read the notice carefully, ask the immigration office that handled your case, and take notes.
- Fix the cause: for late payments, for example, build a record of on-time payments.
- Decide when to reapply: the guidelines set no waiting period, but applying again before the cause is fixed is likely to lead to the same result.
Please note that our firm prepares and files applications as a certified immigration filing agent. We do not represent clients in administrative appeals or lawsuits.
FAQ
Q1. Can I apply again after being denied?
Yes. The guidelines set no waiting period, but it is important to resolve the cause of the denial first.
Q2. If I pay my unpaid pension now, is the problem solved?
Clearing the balance is necessary, but it may not fully resolve the issue. The guidelines treat payments not made on time, and past failures to pay, as negative factors in principle.
Q3. I once paid a traffic ticket. Will I be denied?
The guidelines have no specific standard for traffic violations, and the number alone does not decide the outcome. The key questions are whether you received a criminal fine and whether violations were repeated.
Q4. I am married to a Japanese national. Do late tax payments still matter?
Yes. Spouses do not need to meet the good conduct and independent livelihood requirements, but meeting obligations such as paying taxes is reviewed under the national interest requirement.
Talk to us about permanent residence
Inui Immigration Services (Inui Gyoseishoshi Corporation) is a certified immigration filing agent based in Osaka. We prepare permanent residence applications and help you identify risks before you apply. If you have been denied, we can also help you organize the facts for a new application.
We work in English and Japanese, and offer online consultations across Japan as well as meetings at our Osaka office. See our fee schedule, or call 06-6949-8756 (Mon, Tue, Wed, Fri 9:00–17:00 / Thu 9:00–13:00, JST).
➡ Learn more on our Permanent Residence page.
📋 Official sources (Japanese)
- Immigration Services Agency: Permanent Residence (Article 22)
- Guidelines for Permanent Residence, revised October 1, 2026
- Full text of the October 2026 guidelines (PDF)
- Guidelines for Permanent Residence, revised February 24, 2026
- Permanent residence application: procedure and documents
- e-Gov: Administrative Complaint Review Act
This article is based on materials published by the Immigration Services Agency and other government sources as of November 10, 2026. Review practices and required documents may change, so please check the latest information before applying. Nothing in this article guarantees approval.
Supervised by
乾 喜満(いぬい よしみつ)
Gyoseishoshi (Administrative Scrivener) / Representative, Inui Gyoseishoshi Corporation
Registration No.: 16260979
Founded 2016. Specializes in Japan residence status and naturalization. Available in 5 languages (JA/EN/ZH/KO/VI). Based in Osaka Tenjinbashi.


Comments